Choosing the right chew for your dog can be challenging with so many options on the market. Reddit users have shared their tried-and-true favorites, and one product stands out: the Benebone Wishbone. Praised for its durability and ability to keep dogs entertained for months, this chew toy is the clear favorite among dog owners. To help you find the perfect match for your furry friend, we’ve compiled a list of the six best dog chews, highlighting their unique features, benefits, and what makes them stand out.
Quick Picks: Best Dog Chews of 2025
- Best Overall: Benebone Wishbone
- Best Natural Option: Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks
- Best for Treat-Stuffing Fun: Kong Classic Dog Toy
- Best Flavored Chew: Nylabone DuraChew
- Best Healthy Alternative to Rawhide: Himalayan Dog Chews
- Best for Aggressive Chewers: JimHodgesDogTraining Grade A Premium Elk Antlers
Best Dog Chews of 2025: Reddit’s Top Picks
1. Benebone Wishbone (Best Overall)
The Benebone Wishbone is a Reddit favorite for good reason. Designed to mimic a dog’s natural chewing instinct, its ergonomic shape and durable construction ensure hours of entertainment. It’s infused with real flavors like bacon, which keeps dogs engaged and coming back for more. The sturdy nylon material is tough enough to handle aggressive chewers, making it a great investment for durability. Additionally, its unique wishbone shape allows dogs to easily grip it during their chew sessions.
Pros:
- Extremely durable, even for aggressive chewers.
- Infused with natural flavors to maintain interest.
Cons:
- Must be replaced when it gets small to avoid choking hazards.
- Not suitable for dogs with sensitive teeth.
Read full Benebone Wishbone review
2. Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks (Best Natural Option)
Nature Gnaws Bully Sticks are an all-natural, fully digestible option perfect for dogs of all sizes. Made from a single ingredient—beef pizzle—these chews are free from additives and preservatives. Reddit users appreciate their safety and the hours of chewing enjoyment they provide. These sticks are particularly beneficial for dogs with sensitive stomachs, as they are gentle on the digestive system. Despite their higher cost, their safety and natural appeal make them a top choice for health-conscious pet owners.
Pros:
- Made from natural ingredients with no additives.
- Fully digestible and safe for most dogs.
Cons:
- Can be pricey for frequent use.
- Odor may be off-putting to some pet owners.
3. Kong Classic Dog Toy (Best for Treat-Stuffing Fun)
The Kong Classic Dog Toy is a must-have for any dog owner. This versatile chew toy can be stuffed with treats or peanut butter, offering a fun and interactive experience for your pet. Its durable rubber construction makes it suitable for moderate chewers, and its unique shape ensures unpredictable bounces, adding to the fun. The Kong also doubles as a tool for managing separation anxiety by keeping your dog engaged and mentally stimulated.
Pros:
- Can be stuffed with treats for interactive play.
- Durable and easy to clean.
Cons:
- Not ideal for extremely aggressive chewers.
- Requires supervision to avoid ingestion of small pieces.
4. Nylabone DuraChew (Best Flavored Chew)
For dogs that love flavored chews, the Nylabone DuraChew is a top contender. Infused with appealing flavors like chicken or bacon, it keeps dogs engaged longer than traditional chews. The tough nylon construction ensures durability, making it a great choice for heavy chewers. However, it’s essential to monitor your dog’s use, as aggressive chewing can cause small pieces to break off over time.
Pros:
- Flavored to hold a dog’s interest.
- Durable for prolonged use.
Cons:
- Too tough for dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Can splinter if chewed aggressively.
5. Himalayan Dog Chews (Best Healthy Alternative to Rawhide)
Himalayan Dog Chews are a healthier alternative to rawhide, made from yak and cow milk. Their dense texture provides a satisfying chewing experience, while their natural ingredients make them a safer option for your pup. These chews also help clean your dog’s teeth by scraping away plaque and tartar. While they are pricier than other options, their long-lasting nature makes them a cost-effective choice in the long run.
Pros:
- Made from natural ingredients, with no additives.
- Long-lasting and safe for digestion.
Cons:
- Expensive compared to other options.
- Can be too hard for dogs with weaker teeth.
6. JimHodgesDogTraining Grade A Premium Elk Antlers (Best for Aggressive Chewers)
Elk antlers are a fantastic choice for dogs that are aggressive chewers. JimHodgesDogTraining Grade A Premium Elk Antlers are natural, long-lasting, and packed with minerals. They’re less messy than traditional chews and help maintain dental health. Additionally, elk antlers provide essential nutrients like calcium and phosphorus, making them more than just a chew toy—they’re a health booster too.
Pros:
- Natural and rich in minerals.
- Long-lasting and ideal for aggressive chewers.
Cons:
- Can splinter if chewed aggressively.
- Expensive upfront cost.
What to Consider When Buying Dog Chews
When choosing the best chew for your dog, keep the following factors in mind:
- Chewing Style: Determine whether your dog is a gentle, moderate, or aggressive chewer. This will help you select a chew with the right durability.
- Size and Safety: Choose a chew that’s appropriately sized for your dog to prevent choking hazards.
- Ingredients: Opt for natural, non-toxic ingredients to ensure your dog’s health and safety. For example, the American Veterinary Medical Association highlights the importance of choosing safe and non-toxic chews to prevent harm.
- Dental Benefits: Look for chews that promote dental health by reducing plaque and tartar buildup.
- Longevity: Consider how long the chew will last, especially if your dog tends to go through chews quickly.
Key Concerns When Buying Dog Chews
While dog chews can provide numerous benefits, there are some concerns to watch out for:
- Choking Hazards: Some chews, like the Benebone Wishbone, need to be replaced once they become too small to avoid choking risks.
- Digestibility: Ensure the chew is fully digestible to prevent intestinal blockages. The FDA’s guidelines on pet treat safety emphasize choosing digestible options to avoid potential health issues.
- Hardness: Overly hard chews, such as antlers, may cause tooth fractures in some dogs.
- Allergies: Check for any potential allergens in the chew’s ingredients.
- Cost: Higher-quality chews often come with a higher price tag, so consider your budget alongside your dog’s needs.
Final Verdict: The Clear Winner
After scouring Reddit for the most recommended dog chews, the Benebone Wishbone emerges as the top choice. Its durability, ergonomic design, and natural flavors make it the best overall option for keeping dogs entertained and satisfied. While each chew on this list has its unique benefits, the Benebone Wishbone consistently delivers the best combination of longevity, safety, and engagement. When it comes to your furry friend, settling for less simply isn’t an option.
